For the last fifteen years or so I’ve been using alcohol/dye based markers to make art. Mostly I’ve used them for my “Covers to Comic Books That Don’t Exist” series. I like them. They have bright and consistent color that blend well and I only buy brands that have refill inks so that I can refill the markers when they run dry.
The main downside to dye based markers is that the dye, and therefore the color, is fugitive. It’s not archival and with the passages of time and exposure to light the color will fade. Not tomorrow but some time in the future. This is something I’ve had to come to terms with in working with these markers. Nothing has faded yet but I know it will someday.
That brings me to a statement that I learned in art history class though I don’t remember who said it. It was along the lines of, “Do you want to make something good that lasts a day or a piece of crap that lasts forever?” It’s a little binary and I’m sure there are lots of shades in between those two extremes but I think about that idea a lot. I probably wouldn’t be doing this series of works without the markers so maybe it’s okay if the color fades someday.
I scan in all the pieces so there will be a record of them as long as the digital files last. Plus the black line on the covers is done with India ink and that’s archival. Someday when the color is gone the line drawing will still be there. It started as a line drawing and it’ll end up as one. There is a little poetry to that.
That brings us to the new Pantone markers that I bought last year. Instead of being alcohol/dye based they are water/pigment based. The pigments are much more lightfast and archival. They shouldn’t fade anytime soon.
I started making my pieces with the Pantone markers (which are refillable) and even added some Pitt and Staedtler brush pens to the mix. Both of those use pigment but aren’t refillable. Those two brands are also smaller than the Pantone markers and not as good at laying down large areas of color. But they’re good for details.
I haven’t even had them a year yet but I’ve learned to use the pigment based markers pretty well. They work a little differently than the dye based ones but I’ve developed some techniques for them. At this point I’ve been working with them for almost ten months and I’ve grown to like them.
That brings me to the question of do I still want to use my dye based markers? I have a lot of them and a lot of refill inks for them. Do I just want to abandon them? I liked them just fine before I got the pigment based ones. Is the fact that they’re not archival mean that I should give them up? I was okay with them fading away over time before so why not now? By the way none of the pieces I’ve done over the last fifteen years have even started to fade.
In contemplating that question I actually picked up and used those dye based markers today. I usually draw my “Covers to Comic Books That Don’t Exist” series on paper that’s called Bristol Board. It’s a heavy paper and what comic books are usually draw on. It’s not a marker paper though in that it’s very absorbent and sucks up ink. Marker paper is usually a little bit less absorbent so the ink will sit more on top of the paper for better blending.
There are two types of Bristol Board that I buy: Vellum and Smooth. Vellum has a little bit of a rougher surface and feels slightly thicker. Smooth is smoother. I prefer smooth and probably use it over 90% of the time. Except a few weeks ago I ran out of smooth ( I ordered more) so I made a couple of “Covers to Comic Books That Don’t Exist” on the vellum paper. No big deal. I’ve done this before.
The problem came when I went to color the cover with the Pantone markers. Since the paper is rougher than the smooth it would usually absorb even more color when I was working with the dye based markers. I was used to that. But with the pigment based markers the color sat on the surface and stayed wet for a while. I’m talking twenty minutes. I have no idea why.
I discovered this when, as I was drawing, I unknowingly set my hand in the wet ink and then as I moved my hand around it left blotches of color behind. As you might image I was confused by this and it made me have to be very mindful of how I laid the color down and where I put my hand.
I managed to color two covers on that paper with my Pantone markers and I switched back to my regular paper as soon as I got some. But there were still a couple on the vellum paper in the pipeline.
Yesterday as I was contemplating what I wanted to work on I looked at a cover that was on the vellum paper and ready to color. I wasn’t really in the mood to be extra patient with it as I would have to be with the Pantone markers. That’s when I decided that it was okay to use the dye based ones. It would be okay.
So that’s what I did today. Despite a bit of a layoff from using the alcohol markers it was easy going. I have been using them for fifteen years so that shouldn’t be a surprise but you never know. That’s one of the crazy things about creativity. After a layoff in doing something the fear that you won’t be able to anymore always makes one doubt. But that’s another line of thought for another day.



